Is Switzerland Introducing a Trust Law?

Is Switzerland Introducing a Trust Law?

On a governmental level, the introduction of a Swiss law on trusts is currently being reviewed as Switzerland does not provide for a suitable instrument to be used for estate planning or asset protection purposes.

Arguments for the introduction of a Swiss Trust Law

It is argued that an introduction would have various advantages, for example citizens would be offered an instrument that is subject to the domestic legal system being more accessible and easier to understand, and providing clarity, leading to greater transparency and legal certainty. In addition, new areas of activity would be created for Swiss professionals to advise on trusts, to set up trusts and to manage trusts and their assets.

Is a Swiss Trust a suitable instrument?

Many scholars and practitioners take the view, that a common-law trust is not a suitable instrument and that therefore it would be more advisable to review the existing instruments, such as the Swiss family foundation or the fiducie (Treuhand), and to amend them accordingly.

One of the main concerns is that ownership cannot be split into legal and beneficial ownership. To be the owner, a trustee must have all property rights in the assets while the beneficiaries have personal rights against the trustee only. Thus, the common law trust concept would need to be amended in order to fit into the Swiss legal system.

What would be the tax implications?

So far, most foreign trusts are treated tax transparent for Swiss tax purposes based on an economic assumption that the settlor has not given the assets fully away if he is either a beneficiary or retained certain rights such as amending the trust deed, appointing and/or removing a trustee or changing the beneficiaries. In this case, the funds and the income therefrom are still allocated to a Swiss resident settlor with the respective tax consequences.

This transparent tax treatment can be advantageous as no transfer tax is levied when settling the trust.

With the introduction of Swiss trust law it is not clear yet whether such transparent treatment would remain. There is currently an expert group analysing if a Swiss trust could become subject tax in Switzerland. If this was the case, it is likely that no Swiss trust law will be introduced.

Outlook

If and when a trust law will be introduced is not clear yet. However, it will take at least another 3 to 4 years for an implementation. As the already existing family foundation could be a suitable civil law instrument, it would be feasible to analyse the existing obstacles for the use of Swiss family foundations and to amend these provisions at the same time. https://blumgrob.ch/

RFF Lawyers is a tax law “boutique” firm in Portugal, specialized in tax and business law, both for corporate and institutional entities and individual clients. Rogério and his team at RFF Lawyers seek to foster lasting relationships - of confidence and trust - and to provide the proper legal solutions meeting the specific needs of each client, whether individual or corporate. 

Rogério Fernandes Ferreira

Rogério Fernandes Ferreira

RFF Lawyers

Dr. Natalie Peter works as an attorney-of-law in Zurich and is heading the private client practice of Blum & Grob Attorneys-at-law.

Trust law

Natalie Peter

Blum Grob
Swiss Family Foundations: Ensuring Stability, Protection, and Continuity

Swiss Family Foundations: Ensuring Stability, Protection, and Continuity

The Family Foundation is used hesitantly in Swiss succession and estate planning, although in recent years, the establishment of a foundation has been increasingly evaluated again. 

A robust estate planning ensures a reliable regulation and avoidance of conflicts amongst heirs. In each case, a tailor-made structure must be determined. While a testator may want to commit family assets over several generations to his family, another may seek avoidance of long inheritance proceedings or high inheritance taxes. Yet, other families seek anonymity and asset protection. A foundation may also be used in cases where an entrepreneur has no descendants suitable for succession or if he wants to ensure long-term continuity of his company.

The use of a Family Foundation

A Swiss testator is faced with narrow rules limiting his or her estate planning options. Relatively high compulsory portions (forced heirship rules) encumber a free transfer of assets to heirs of the testator’s choice. Therefore, the use of a family foundation has rarely been considered in a pure Swiss family situation. However, since families are often spread over different countries and continents and assets are located in various jurisdictions, contributions of assets to foundations maybe an optimal solution.

The main purposes of a Swiss Family Foundation

The Swiss Civil Code permits the establishment of family (maintenance) foundations “to meet the costs of education, equipment or support of family members or similar purposes“. The purposes have in common that assistance is to be provided to family members in certain situations, such as in adolescence, when setting-up their own household, or live on their own, and in case of need.

Educational costs include both the cost of basic and of continuing education at universities, apprenticeship schools and other educational institutions. The term equipment as of today includes payments that serve to establish, secure or improve a livelihood, in particular when starting a household, getting married or taking up self-employment. The concept of endowment is to be interpreted broadly and understood to be an allocation of assets of a certain size and value. As is the case for benefits under the title “education”, distributions do not require an actual need or emergency situation of a beneficiary. The support of family members finally requires a situation of need of the beneficiary.

Beneficiaries are individually determined family members

The Civil Code prohibits the permanent confinement of assets in favour of a particular family combined with unconditional distributions for an indefinite period. Thus, a Family Foundation may grant a special right to receive benefits to an individual or to individually determined family members instead of family members in general. A founder may reserve for himself or for certain individuals rights to use, enjoy or exploit the assets contributed to the foundation and/or its earnings. These individuals may include heirs who are willing to renounce their compulsory portion in favour of the foundation or other related persons such as cohabiting partners, relatives, or friends.

Special rights my include a usufruct on all or part of the foundation’s assets, residential rights or payments in favour of a specific person. Although family members cannot receive an unconditional benefit in their capacity as a beneficiary, it is possible to provide the spouse, the descendants or grandchildren with general distributions for their cost of living, if they are individually determined in a special right.

Business Foundations

A Business or Holding Foundation is a special form developed by practice and not explicitly regulated by law. A business foundation is characterized by its proximity to the economy. If an entrepreneur has no descendants suitable for succession, the settlement of a Business Foundation could be a temporary bridging measure until the succession is settled. The establishment of a Business Foundation can on the other hand ensure the long-term continuity of the company. https://blumgrob.ch/

RFF Lawyers is a tax law “boutique” firm in Portugal, specialized in tax and business law, both for corporate and institutional entities and individual clients. Rogério and his team at RFF Lawyers seek to foster lasting relationships - of confidence and trust - and to provide the proper legal solutions meeting the specific needs of each client, whether individual or corporate. 

Rogério Fernandes Ferreira

Rogério Fernandes Ferreira

RFF Lawyers
Trust law

Natalie Peter

Blum Grob